The Two Hollywoods






On March 20, 1948, the elite of Hollywood, braving freezing temperatures and gale-force winds, filed past the newsreel cameras into the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles for the twentieth annual presentation of the Academy Awards. Once inside, they discovered a stage that had been transformed into a towering birthday cake, with twenty giant Oscar statuettes in place of candles.

The studios had much to celebrate that night. Their movies, the most democratic of all art forms, had become the principal mode of paid entertainment for the vast majority of Americans. In an average week in 1947, 90 million Americans, out of a total population of only 151 million, went to a movie, paying on the average forty cents for a ticket. Nor was this massive outpouring, about two thirds of the ambulatory population, the product of expensive national marketing campaigns. It was simply the result of regular moviegoers going to see whatever was playing at their neighborhood theaters.

Most of these moviegoers didn’t go to the theater to see a particular film. They went to see a program that included a newsreel; a short comedy film, such as the Three Stooges; a serial, such as Flash Gordon; animated cartoons, such as Bugs Bunny; a B feature, such as a western; and finally, the main attraction. In 1947 in America, movie houses were more ubiquitous than banks. There were more than eighteen thousand neighborhood theaters. Each had only one auditorium, one screen, one speaker (located behind the screen), one projection booth, and one marquee. Every week, usually on Thursday, a UPS truck picked up the previous week’s reels and delivered the new ones. The new film’s title on the marquee and the listings for it in the local newspapers constituted all the advertising most movies got.

Virtually all of these movies and shorts came from regional exchanges owned and operated by seven distribution companies that were, in turn, owned by seven Hollywood studios: Paramount, Universal, MGM, Twentieth Century–Fox, Warner Bros., Columbia, and RKO. In little over a generation, these studios had perfected a nearly omnipotent mechanism for controlling what the American public saw and heard. It was known, collectively, as the studio system.

These studios had their common origins in the arcades, nickelodeons, and exhibition halls of the silent-film era. Their founders, self-made and self-educated Jews, had been part of the late-nineteenth- and earlytwentieth- century wave of immigration from Eastern Europe. They had worked at menial jobs as ragpickers, furriers, errand boys, butchers, junk peddlers, and salesmen and then gone into the business of showing movies. Here they found an enthusiastic audience, especially among those not yet fully literate in English, and a great deal of competition for it. To rise above their competitors, they instinctively sought what later economists would call “economies of scale.” Louis B. Mayer, the founder of MGM, borrowed money to expand from a single theater in Haverhill, Massachusetts, to a small group of theaters that he combined into a “circuit”—so called because the reels of a single movie could be sent by bicycle from one theater to the next (with showtimes cut so close that sometimes one theater was showing the first reel of a film while another theater was showing the last), allowing multiple screenings of—and multiple admissions for—the movies he rented from film exchanges. As their circuits expanded, these entrepreneurs began opening their own film exchanges and distributing movies to other theater owners, but they still made most of their money from tickets bought at their own box office— so called because the cash went into locked boxes.

When they found that they could not get enough movies on a regular basis from independent moviemakers, these new distributors took the next step and started making their own films. Initially, their studios were in the East, but as their production expanded after the turn of the century, they came under increased pressure from the Edison Trust, the legal entity formed by Thomas A. Edison to control the basic patents on movie cameras and projectors in America. The Trust filed a constant stream of lawsuits against the nascent film companies, who finally decided to relocate their studios a continent’s width away from the reach of the Trust’s East Coast lawyers. They chose the newly incorporated village of Hollywood, California—a place they could control—for their new home. In less than a generation, these entrepreneurs had literally gone from rags (or furs) to riches. By the 1940s, the studio heads were among the highest-paid executives in the world. Having come from poverty, they reveled in this wealth and dubbed themselves moguls—an appellation that, although perhaps not strictly appropriate since it originally referred to absolute Moslem rulers, became part of their identity. Louis B. Mayer, who had scavenged rags as a newly arrived immigrant and at nineteen did not have, as his son-in-law David O. Selznick later put it, “the price of a sandwich,” was in 1947 the highest-paid executive in America, with an annual salary from MGM of $1.8 million.

The studios produced nearly five hundred films in 1947—features and B movies. While marketing strategies varied slightly from studio to studio, the movie business in 1947 was a relatively simple affair. The studios did not license their films to television or other media or license their characters for toys, games, T-shirts, or other merchandise. Foreign markets provided some revenue, but that income was mostly offset by high taxes—Britain had a 75 percent import tax, for example—and most European and Asian countries had restrictions on currency repatriation. As a result, profits from abroad were almost impossible to retrieve.

In short, studios looked to a single source for virtually all their money: the American box office. In 1947 the six major studios earned over 95 percent of their revenue from their share of ticket sales (called “rentals,” since it was technically the “rent” theaters paid for films) at North American movie houses. This came to $1.1 billion, which made movies, after grocery stores and automotive sales, America’s third-largest retail business.

The studios were able to harvest this windfall extremely efficiently because they controlled almost all the movie theaters. MGM, Warner Bros., Paramount, Twentieth Century–Fox, and RKO had their own theater chains, which produced about half of their total revenue, while Columbia and Universal controlled chains of theaters less directly through their distribution arms. Among the theaters under studio control were most of the first-run houses in major cities in the United States and Canada, where films had their premieres. During these first runs, films got their reviews, garnered publicity, and generated the word of mouth that served as the principal form of advertising. Thanks to their direct ownership of the theaters, studios were able to determine where, when, and for how long their films played in their first run. Such engagements could extend for many months while studios prepared the subsequent release to neighborhood theaters. For example, in 1947, Samuel Goldwyn’s The Best Years of Our Lives was still playing at New York’s Astor Theater, owned by MGM through its Loews subsidiary, six months after its premiere. In addition, the studios indirectly controlled almost all independently owned theaters, which included most of the neighborhood and secondrun movie houses, through ironclad contracts that forced the theater owners to commit to show a given number of films (usually ten) in a socalled block. If they did not accept a block, they got no studio films at all—which meant they did not have the star names to attract an audience. Only a few dozen art theaters that showed foreign films could afford to turn down this “blind-bidding” arrangement.

Not only were the studios able to control the bookings of their films, but they enjoyed a monopoly on the resulting revenue. Stars, directors, writers, and other talent did not share in it. Neither did producers. In rare cases these participants might receive a share of the eventual profits, but never of the studio’s rentals.

The studios were further aided by low distribution and marketing costs. Because films opened in only a handful of theaters in major cities before moving on to other regions, the same prints and posters could be used first in the Northeast and later on in the South and West. Distribution costs therefore were low, averaging only about $60,000 a film in 1947. Further, there were no national advertising campaigns, and since theaters paid a good part of local advertising and stars freely supplied the publicity on radio and in newsreels, the advertising budgets averaged less than $30,000 a picture.

What remained after these distribution and advertising costs were deducted from the rental revenue were the studios’ net receipts.  In 1947 these totaled approximately $950 million.

To ensure a profit, studios obviously had to produce their films for less money than their net receipts totaled. To maximize their economies of scale, each studio had organized what amounted to a film factory, with staff and equipment that could operate around the clock. On their soundstages, shadowless light was cast by vast arrays of arc lamps, artificial weather was whipped up by wind, rain, and snow machines, and seas were created in indoor pools. On their back lots, exotic locales could be replicated and filled with extras dressed from the stocks of costumes and other props stored in their warehouses. For example, in 1947, MGM shot the adventure movie The Three Musketeers, which was set in seventeenth- century France, entirely on its soundstages and back lots.

The studios’ technological apparatus included synchronous background projection, which allowed them to seamlessly integrate actors in current films with stock footage from their extensive film libraries and with film shot elsewhere by second units. They also had animation cameras to convert miniaturized models, puppets, and other replicas into the illusion of full-scale phenomena. To do all this, a veritable army of electricians, camera operators, seamstresses, makeup artists, set dressers, sound engineers, and other technicians were paid weekly wages. The MGM studio in Culver City, which in 1947 was the largest of the studios, could churn out on its soundstages six different films at the same time. With the aid of these assembly-line facilities, feature films could be shot in less than a month, and some B films were shot in a week.

Under this factory system, studios were also able to keep a tight rein over their product. Frank Capra wrote in a letter to The New York Times in 1939 that “about six producers today pass on about 90 percent of the scripts and edit about 90 percent of the pictures.”    These producers reported to the studio chief, who was directly responsible to the studio’s owners.

The studios also had locked up all the stars who attracted audiences to movie theaters in a contractual arrangement called the star system. In 1947, 487 actors and actresses—including such marquee names as Bing Crosby, Bob Hope, Betty Grable, Gary Cooper, Ingrid Bergman, Humphrey Bogart, Clark Gable, John Wayne, Alan Ladd, and Gregory Peck— were under such contracts. Since these contracts usually ran seven years, precluded the actors from working elsewhere, and had renewal options, the stars were, for that period at least, essentially the studios’ chattel. They had to play every part and perform every bit of publicity assigned to them. If they balked, they could be suspended without pay, as Lana Turner was in 1947 by MGM when she initially refused a part in The Three Musketeers. With no further recourse and facing the prospect of not being allowed to work at the height of her stardom, she finally acceded to MGM’s casting and played the part. In addition, studios could rent stars out to other studios for more than their salaries and pocket the difference. Joan Crawford, under contract to MGM, was loaned to Columbia for They All Kissed the Bride in 1942; and Bette Davis, under contract to Warner Bros., was loaned to RKO for The Little Foxes in 1941.

The contracts also usually gave the studios control of the stars’ public image to further their publicity campaigns for their movies. This meant, in practice, that studios could script stars’ interviews and dictate their public utterances, photographic poses, and gossip-column items. They could order them to alter their facial appearance, hair color, biographical details, and, as was commonly done, their name. Issur Danielovitch, for example, had his name changed to Kirk Douglas, Marion Morrison to John Wayne, and Emanuel Goldenberg to Edward G. Robinson. In return, the studios provided their contract actors with an annual salary, roles in major films, and publicity in the media that they owned or controlled, which included newsreels and fan magazines. Whatever publicity benefits stars enjoyed by being contractually linked to a studio, however, their salaries were relatively low compared with the additional revenue they produced at the box office. In 1947 even highly successful stars, such as Clark Gable, made on averag less than $100,000 a film. Until their contracts ran their course, stars could not increase their fees as they became more popular with audiences and more prominent in the entertainment media. The star system, in effect, allowed the studios to brand their products via the personas they had created—for example, a James Cagney gangster film, a Roy Rogers western, a Clark Gable romance —and take the full profits from them.

By locking in actors’ salaries, Hollywood studios were able to control the cost of manufacturing their products. Indeed, virtually all their films made money. Since the average cost of producing a film in 1947, including all studio overhead, was only $732,000, and the average net receipts for a studio feature amounted to $1.6 million, filmmaking was a lucrative enterprise for studios. Less successful films might eke out a profit of only a few thousand dollars, but the hits that appealed to a broad adult audience, like The Best Years of Our Lives, made profits in excess of $5 million. But the studio moguls wanted more from their invention than mere profits. Not entirely secure with their rapid ascent to wealth, they also wanted the kind of respect, admiration, and status that would reinforce their position. This social part of the equation had been formally recognized some twenty years earlier, in 1927, at a dinner at the Ambassador Hotel, when Louis Mayer had proposed to thirty-five other top studio executives that they institute a way to honor Hollywood’s (i.e., their own) achievements. The result was the establishment of the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences and its annual ritual of bestowing honors in the form of Academy Awards.

The Oscar for the Best Motion Picture of 1947 went to Twentieth Century–Fox’s Gentleman’s Agreement. Adapted from the book of the same title by Laura Z. Hobson, the black-and-white film included the studio contract players Gregory Peck, Celeste Holm, John Garfield, and Dorothy McGuire. The Moss Hart script, like those of most of Hollywood’s feature films, had all the elements of a classic narrative: a beginning, a middle, and an end; rising and falling action; conflict, confrontation, and resolution. It also had a character with whom the audience could readily identify in Philip Green (Gregory Peck), a gentile magazine writer who pretended to be Jewish so he could report firsthand on anti- Semitism. The conflict was almost entirely an intellectual one, resolved without mayhem or bloodshed. Nor was there any sex, nudity, profanity, or even suggestive language, all of which was proscribed by the studios’ own censorship system.

Director Elia Kazan also won an Oscar for Gentleman’s Agreement. The thirty-eight-year-old stage director had been retained by Twentieth Century–Fox after the studio had bought the book, commissioned and approved Moss Hart’s script, and assigned all the major roles to its contract stars. Like almost all other directors under the studio system, Kazan arrived at the beginning of principal photography and departed when it ended. The director’s job was to exact the best performance from the actors and technicians within a shooting schedule prepared by the studio.

Twentieth Century–Fox executives, including studio head Darryl F. Zanuck, reviewed Kazan’s daily progress during the twelve weeks of production. Zanuck then supervised the film’s editing and musical score. Absolute authority over the creative process had been invested in the studio head ever since Irving Thalberg at MGM had perfected the system in the late 1920s. Zanuck had produced 170 of Fox’s films, and Gentleman’s Agreement, which he had supervised from start to finish, was no exception.

When Kazan accepted the Oscar for Gentleman’s Agreement that night, the film was still, four months after opening at the Mayfair Theater in New York, in its first run. Even at this point, without having yet moved to neighborhood theaters, it had already earned back the $2 million it had cost to make. Although it was a cerebral film intended mainly for adults, it could reasonably be expected to draw a much larger audience once it was released more widely because, like all studio features, it would be part of a theater program that included a B film for teenage audiences and cartoons for children.

On that cold night in March 1948, all the signs seemed to indicate that the system was still operating almost flawlessly, and many of the old faces were there to attest to it. For the Academy Awards’ twentieth anniversary, all the original moguls were present except Carl Laemmle, the founder of Universal, who had died, and William Fox, the founder of Twentieth Century–Fox, who, after nearly succeeding in taking over MGM in 1929, had gone bankrupt and then to prison for attempting to bribe a judge in his bankruptcy case. But if there is one lesson Hollywood teaches, it is that looks can be deceiving, and in 1948 the world of American moviemaking was on the verge of radical and irreversible change.

Although it was not evident in their demeanor that night, the power elites gathered at the awards ceremony knew that ominous storm clouds were amassing on the horizon. Hollywood was becoming the principal target of the House Un-American Activities Committee’s efforts to uncover Communist subversion. In 1947 a large number of writers, actors, and directors had been called before the committee and asked to name subversives in the film industry. Many of those who refused to cooperate were then cited for contempt of Congress, and ten of them, the so-called Hollywood Ten, had to choose between prison and flight from the country. Caught in this bind, many leading writers—including Joseph Losey, Ben Barzman, and Donald Ogden Stewart—had moved abroad to avoid being subpoenaed.

The studios, rather than defying the congressional inquisition, had declared that anyone who invoked his or her constitutional right against self-incrimination or refused to cooperate by naming names would be fired and blacklisted. The Screen Actors Guild, headed by Ronald Reagan, in turn supported the studios, which had hired ex–FBI agents to help them weed out employees who had a politically suspect past. The smiles and jokes during the awards ceremony notwithstanding, the ugly issue of what constituted loyalty was threatening to tear apart the social fabric of the film community.

Another cloud was even darker and more threatening. For nearly ten years, in U.S. v. Paramount et al., the Justice Department had been pressing an antitrust suit against the studios, alleging that the studios’ control over the means by which movies were distributed and exhibited constituted an illegal restraint of trade under the Sherman Anti-Trust Act. The lower courts had decided in favor of the Justice Department, and the studios were running out of appeals. To settle the case, the government had demanded that the studios end their block booking and divest themselves of either their distribution arms or their theaters. In either case, they would lose control over what was shown—and that control, as every studio owner realized, was the jugular of the studio system. RKO—the weakest of the studios—was on the verge of breaking ranks and signing a consent decree. If it did, the other studios would come under tremendous, if not irresistible, pressure to follow suit. And once they did, the studio system would be dead.

The darkest cloud on the horizon, however, was the advent of an alternative entertainment medium: television. To be sure, at that point the new technology offered only a few hours of primitive programming a day in black and white, but it offered that at no cost to the consumer. Advertisers, not the audience, paid the broadcasters. The Hollywood studios had attempted to hobble this infant medium, if not kill it, by refusing to let the networks show films from their libraries or use their facilities to produce programs. Nevertheless, the television broadcasters were finding alternatives: live sports, news, game shows, and independent movies. And, although there were only 1 million sets in American homes in 1947, television manufacturers were expecting that number to quadruple by 1949. If these projections were realized, it would only be a matter of time before a good part of the 90 million people who paid to see movies at theaters would choose instead to watch free television. Since the studios were almost entirely dependent on this audience for their revenues, any substantial decrease would be an economic disaster.



The US has the oldest film industry and largest in terms of revenue. Los Angeles is the primary mecca for the American film industry. Other cities are known for there influence in the film industry New York City is a classic filming destination as well as Las Vegas.   Las Vegas and New York
have the flare and appeal that many directors and producers love. These directors and producers have made hotels in New York City as well as Las Vegas hotels famous throughout the world. The Plaza hotel and MGM Grand are just two hotels made famous by movies.

Questions? Email me at eje@nyc/ The webmistress can be reached at